Skip to content
FocalIDFocalID

Build or buy? How to choose business software

Every business that needs new software faces the same choice: buy a product that exists, or have one built. Both can be right. The decision turns on how standard the process is and how much it sets you apart from competitors.

By the FocalID team in Colombo, , 2 min read

Hand tools hanging in neat rows on a workshop wall.

When buying is right

Buy when the process is the same in most companies: accounting, payroll, email, basic CRM. A product gives you years of other customers’ experience, it is ready now, and the supplier keeps it up to date with changes in law and technology. Changing your process slightly to fit a good product is usually cheaper than building your own.

When building is right

Build when the process is how you win customers or save money in a way competitors do not, and no product fits it without heavy bending. Build also when the available products would need so much customising that you would be maintaining custom software anyway, on someone else’s platform.

Costs people forget

BuyingBuilding
Up-frontSet-up, configuration, data migration, trainingDesign, development, testing, data migration, training
OngoingLicence per user, which rises as you growHosting, support and improvements
Often missedCustomisation, integrations, paying for features you never useTime from your own staff to specify and test
If you part waysGetting your data out and moving to another productFinding another team to maintain the code

Compare the two over five years, not on the first invoice.

Questions to ask

  • Is this process a real advantage, or just the way we have always done it?
  • Does a product cover most of what we need without customising?
  • Can we get our data out in a usable format if we leave?
  • Does the product have an API so other systems can connect to it?
  • If we build, who will own and maintain it in three years?

The usual answer is both

Most companies do best with products for the standard work and custom software only where they are different, connected so data flows between them. Buy the accounting system. Build the pricing engine or the dispatch screen that nobody else has.

Common questions

Is custom software always more expensive?

Not over time. Licence fees for many users over several years can exceed the cost of building and maintaining a focused system.

How long does custom software take?

A focused first version is usually a matter of months. Starting with the smallest useful version keeps that short.

Who owns custom software?

That depends on the contract. Make sure it gives you ownership of the code and the data.

Related